Monday, June 11, 2007

The journey as reward

Major Spoiler Alert (Do not read if you choose not to know what happened on the final "Sopranos"): David Chase's 86th and final installment of "The Sopranos" was an artistic masterpiece. The last scene, despised, it seems, by a surprisingly large number of people, encapsulated every thing that made the series great-- in particular, the heightening of tension and a stubborn refusal to fall into any category that has come before. The episode, entitled "Made In America," is destined to accomplish that which is the most difficult thing to achieve in the visual arts-- reward progressively more with each subsequent viewing. If it wasn't your cup of tea, I take no pleasure in informing you that you've just witnessed the future of television.

Much of America wanted the long-running narrative of the Soprano family to come to an end last night without any loose ends. (Blogger Ken Levine is still hoping that Carmela and her father will get the construction bid for the new Yankee Stadium, and that Junior will become a presidential advisor .) Instead, it concluded decidedly perfect in its imperfection. In terms of conveying Chase's ultimate message, the A.J. Soprano character carried the ball over the goal line. Anthony and Carmela's son experienced an existential crisis during the series' final season. Following his uncle Bobby's funeral Sunday, he chided his dinner companions for "watching these jack-off fantasies on TV," with the words boaring through television sets across the North American continent, "You people are fucked. You're living in a fucking dream!" By the end of the hour, though, Che Soprano was dead-- bought off by his parents, and forsaking a dangerous, but meaningful career in the military as a liaison officer for a position on the film crew of Little Carmine Lupertazzi's next splatter-fest, "Anti-Virus." The cycle of destruction continues.

Even the multitude of viewers who say they enjoyed the final episode seemed to miss the point. The series didn't end on an ambiguous note so that it might one day be primed for revival or film adaptation. You heard it here first-- "The Sopranos" is gone for good. It's history. The series never existed for its creator as a matter of commerce, the only conceivable purpose for keeping it alive. That was the beauty of it. It's something damn near impossible to achieve in this country, actually. There were never any sponsors or advertisers to risk offending. It's timing was such that it became bigger than its network. Chase had complete artistic freedom from his distributor and financiers, and the complete faith and confidence of his employees. For David Chase, it was what every artist dreams of having, but rarely achieves.

As a loyal viewer with high expectations, I found plenty of tiny bows to wrap on Chase's monumental gift to the world Sunday night. In fact, I find there's very little uncertainty that still exists in my mind about the fate of these characters. It's quite obvious, you see, that Tony is being shot dead in the final moment by the man who disappeared into the bathroom, an homage to Michael Corleone and "The Godfather." The deafening silence that greeted our post-"Sopranos" existence echoed the conversation Tony had had with his brother-in-law in the first episode of this final season, and was recalled in the penultimate episode last week-- the one about never hearing the gunshot when your time arrives. I welcome any dissent on this hypothesis.

Among the other highlights and poignant swan songs of Sunday night, there were: Tony and Carmela beginning a new and obviously fruitless effort to resolve their personal and marital woes through psychotherapy, validation, I believe, for Dr. Melfi's ultimate abandonment; Meadow's struggle to parallel park her BMW in the closing moments, symbolizing her future problems reconciling her desire to defend the defenseless with her motivation to right the perceived wrongs toward her father, himself an oppressor; hideous justice for Phil Leotardo, and for his wife as well, who I never much liked; and a job promotion for Paulie Walnuts, who, if we can trust that mischievous cat, looks to be in for exactly the justice he deserves as well. The cat was a thing of beauty. If it's a body reincarnated, its staring at the picture of Christopher at the Bing implies that it may be Adriana , or better yet-- Christopher, himself, driving Paulie to distraction and self-doubt--- or best of all, Big Pussy taking a literal form.

In the waning moments of the series, I cherished the expression on Carmela's face when she found out what her daughter's starting salary would likely be if she caught on at a prestigious law firm. The look was equal parts pride and disbelief that she was finally getting what she wanted for her daughter all along, perhaps more than she deserved as her mother. (Edie Falco might just be the best actor we've got.) The most poignant scene was the one between Tony and Uncle Junior. It was so obvious, in retrospect, that the final two-part season would end with a nod to the incident that started the final charge. When Tony, letting down his guard, asked his father's brother, if he remembered Johnny and Junior "running all of North Jersey," I came the closest to tears all evening. The Johnny Boy Soprano character hung like a dark cloud over the entire series. He was the greatest cipher of them all, and I'm glad his image crystallized again so late in the series' final hour.

Finally, I applaud the selection of the final song, "Don't Stop Believing" by Journey. I doubt the song is David Chase's or Steven Van Zandt's favorite, but it is exactly the song that Tony would select on the juke box at the given moment, and undeniably moving if you belong to a certain 25 year demographic range. The given song, at that moment, belongs to the characters, as the concluding scene was edited too suspensefully for the audience to linger over the words: Some will win, some will lose/Some were born to sing the blues/Oh, the movie never ends/It goes on and on and on and on. Not only are the lyrics fitting, but so is the name of the band.

R.I.P. Tony Uncle Johnny.

3 Comments:

At 3:19 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Excellent analysis. From the show's very beginning, Chase has peppered his show's dialogue and imagery with Godfather references, making it nearly impossible not to think of Michael Corleone as the guy goes to the men's room. Still, I can't help but wonder if Chase may be toying with (and laughing at) our desire for finality and closure. Guys piss: it doesn't necessarily mean anything. And there, I think, lies the true beauty of the final scene. I'm reminded of the scene (I go from memory) in the first half of season six, when A.J. breaks down crying after being released from custody for lamely attempting to kill his confused uncle. Pitifully, A.J. laments that Tony loves it when Pacino kills the men who shot his dad. Tony tells his son that it's just a movie, that he needs to grow up. The world of the "Sopranos" is not the world of "The Godfather". Certainly, Chris' case is a strong one, but I prefer to think that we just don't know.

 
At 9:03 PM, Blogger CM said...

You've convinced me.

During a second viewing of the final scene, with the action moving at a much slower clip, it became evident that Tony is glancing up toward the front door and not the bathroom. The bells ring. For the rest of his life, Tony will be forced to wonder who might walk in holding his fate in his hands. He best keep eyes trained on both doors.

Have any of you heard the theory that all of the people sitting in the diner had been touched negatively by Tony in the past? One man, evidently, was robbed at gunpoint by Christopher during Season 2 (?), the boy scouts sitting in the corner were traumatized in the train store when Bobby was shot, and the guy who goes into the bathroom was Phil Leotardo's nephew in Season 5-- adding speculation to the theory that he would come out blasting away at Tony. Hmmmmmm....

 
At 9:53 PM, Blogger Unknown said...

I've been online the last two days reading some of the negative responses, having also read (for weeks)the speculation from fans about ways the show could end, and I keep coming back to the same gut feeling:

This episode was NOT a cop-out, in fact, ANY other ending would have been. It sounds cheesy to say it, but this show transcends any type of tidy conclusion. If Meadow or AJ had died tragically, we'd all be saying it was a Godfather 3 ripoff. If Tony had gone to prison, it wouldn't have been any conclusion because we'd be deprived his trial and what life in prison may be like for him. I contend that the people disappointed in this ending don't even realize it but they would have been even more dissatisfied by the types of conclusions they think they would have preferred.

The simple fact is that most Americans fancy themselves movie and film experts - and rightly so. Most Americans have watched thousands and thousands of hours of TV and understand "the rules". A great show (like the Sopranos) understands that playing by the rules, in 2007, is simply doomed to be a let-down. We've heard it all and seen it all. Yes, we all know the six or seven obvious scenarios David Chase COULD have chosen. Does anybody really wish he'd have chosen one of those? God bless 'em, but maybe this show isn't for the same people who plop down their eight bucks to see a Pirates or Spiderman movie, are genuinely entertained but are never really fooled for a second that their heroes won't still be standing at the end.

What most people don't seem to realize is how genuinely unimportant the ending of most movies and TV are, because we never really doubt what that conclusion will be. But here, then, we have an instance where we have a genuine scenario that could go any number of ways. And for once, it feels so good and so right that it actually MATTERS. Should we really be surprised then that half of the viewers would have picked something "different", after all their hours of speculating in their "fucking dream"?

What Chase gave us instead is the very best conclusion. I'm tempted to phrase it as the best POSSIBLE conclusion, but that would be undermining the genius of this story and would ultimately suggest a "my hands were tied" cop-out, which this wasn't. This was very well thought out and deliberately and brilliantly executed. Understanding also that plot is important (obviously, for structure) but inevitably meaningless when it comes to the way we are affected by screen characters, he gave us the richest, most complex episode yet. The one thing that every fan (even those that hated the ending) seems to acknowledge is that the episode was better the second time they watched it...and the third. This story will continue to grow, because Chase loved and was true to his characters - the only thing that really matters.

I, for one, have rarely been more spellbound and anxious than I was when I watched this episode. Feeling disappointment never occurred to me. I simply wanted to watch it again. Right away.

Loved the tension, the Dylan song, the genius of the different TV clips, Leotardo's head-crushing, the Journey song, the FBI agent stuff and especially the symbolism of the cat, which was fascinating, weird and hilarious. Long live Paulie Walnuts, that poor bastard!!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home